Thursday 14 May 2020

Books and Stories, Part 2: Edith Cavell.


Edith Cavell





One of the books I have currently unearthed is a slim volume on The Dutiful Edith Cavell. In fact, it was finding both books, the one on Bruges in World War One and this Cavell story, which made the connection in my mind. In fact, Edith Cavell was a name from my childhood when her story featured prominently in my beloved Girls' Book of Heroines. I was
thrilled and horrified as a little girl with Edith’s story, often re-told by my mother, born in 1902, and I went, in adulthood, to find her final grave outside the East end of Norwich Cathedral. She had been born nearby, in Swardeston, daughter of the rector there, on December 4, 1865 and fought hard to become a professional nurse, not then a socially acceptable job for a girl of her class. She began her training in 1895 as a probationer nurse at the London Hospital and worked in a number of London hospitals holding increasingly important jobs such as staff nurse, Night Superintendent, Assistant Superintendent, Acting Matron [Manchester] and gaining a reputation as a teacher of nursing.

Edith with students,
Before she began her nursing career, Edith had spent the years 1890-1895 in Brussels as a governess to a French family. In 1906, a leading Belgian doctor, M. Depage, decided to found a surgical and medical home in Brussels and he looked for a highly-trained English nurse, preferably French-speaking. He regarded the current English nursing practices and standards as the best available, far superior to those in Belgium where the Catholic Church had traditionally provided all nursing and hospitals but increasingly lacked knowledge of modern developments. Almost inevitably, he chose Edith for whom the post as Directrice of l’Ecole Belge d’Infirmieres Diplomees seemed created. Her confidence, efficiency and success eventually overcame the huge prejudices she encountered, the most potent of which was the social hostility to a woman of her class working professionally. A particular help in overcoming all this prejudice was given by the then Queen Elisabeth who turned to the Ecole for nursing when she broke her arm. Elisabeth became a vocal supporter of Edith and her Ecole, conferring a powerful respectability and approval on both woman and institution.

By 1914, Edith was Directrice of three hospitals, giving weekly lectures to doctors and nurses and
Princesse Marie de Croy

fast becoming an admired public figure in Brussels. At the outbreak of war, she turned the Berkendael Medical Institute into a Red Cross Hospital. In August 1915, following the Battle of Dinant after which the forts at Namur surrendered, there were thousands of French and Belgian soldiers hiding in the surrounding woods, then, after the defeat at Mons, hundreds of British soldiers on the run joined them, seeking protection and sustenance from local peasants. It was then that Prince Reginald de Croy and his sister, Princesse Marie, whose ancestral home, the Chateau de Bellignies, lay in the Mons area, responded to many requests for help from locals hiding soldiers on the run. The de Croy family instigated what became the Brussels H.Q. of an underground movement for the
organised escape to Holland, of foreign soldiers in hiding in occupied Belgium. Quite soon after its formation, one of those involved asked Edith Cavell if she could consider hiding two fugitive British soldiers and she immediately agreed, thus becoming an important link in the chain of escape. Eventually, one of the ostensible escapees, a German agent, betrayed her and several others and all were arrested, accused of treason. Had the escapees been civilians, the charge would have been less severe but helping soldiers escape [in her case, over 200 men] thus enabling them to fight again, could only be treason, with death as the only penalty. No written evidence against Edith was found but she admitted everything to her German captors after they told her, untruthfully, that others had all confessed and supplied details. Of the thirty five arrested, only five were executed.

Enlistment poster.
In spite of strenuous protests from the American and Spanish embassies, the executions were carried out quietly, early on October 21, 1915. Edith was made to watch one execution before her own; in her turn, she stood unbound with eyes uncovered and the soldiers in the firing party all shot over her head leaving the officer in charge to deliver the coup de grace. The shooting of a woman spy was greeted world-wide with denunciation and horror and Edith’s name became honoured and recognised everywhere. Her execution certainly strengthened the resolve of the Allies and greatly influenced the decision of America to join the war. Interestingly, her death penalty was for “conducting soldiers to the enemy”. This she did not actually do; she hid them to allow others to do the conduction. A few hours after her execution, the German Military Code was amended and the following added:

Whosoever knowingly aids, in any manner whatsoever, such a person,[a person who has wished to aid an enemy of Germany] in concealing his presence, whether by giving him lodging, by clothing him, or by giving him nourishment, is liable to the same punishment. [death]’

Though retrospective, this gave, from the German point of view, a semblance of justice and administrative tidiness. 
Edith's grave in Life's Green, Norwich Cathedral.
Her courage was undoubted but Edith Cavell’s somewhat humourless and dour personality hid considerable kindness, concern for others and selflessness to a high degree. Daughter of a Victorian rector father and brought up with evangelical strictness, the concept of duty ruled her life and provided the foundation for all her life choices including those leading to her death. She had achieved an enormous amount in Brussels before the war in establishing a series of high quality teaching hospitals; in elevating the professional standing and standards of nursing in Belgium; and in changing public perceptions of women working professionally. But perhaps her martyrdom was the most effective persuader for the enduring fame of her life’s work.

The German authorities refused to return her body to England and so she was buried near the prison at Saint Gilles in Brussels but after the war, her body was exhumed and returned to England for a huge service at St Paul’s in London attended both by Royalty and members of the Government. Crowds lined the route from Dover to St Paul’s and after the service, as the cortege journeyed to Norwich Cathedral, many thousands more paid their respects. Her burial, outside the East End of the Cathedral in the grass-covered Life’s Green, took place on May 15, 1919. Her family had chosen this burial site near the place of her birth, in preference to the honour of burial in Westminster Abbey, A
curiously fitting tribute to a woman who never sought glory. And it is worth remembering that Anna de Beir chiefly owed her life to the world-wide scandal caused by the execution of Edith Cavell.


London Memorial.

Tuesday 12 May 2020

Books and Stories Part 1: Anna de Beir

There are photographs of Anna de Beir
and of her pension on Sint Annarei
in this book.
I have failed to find them on the Internet!

John Julius Norwich.
Winston Churchhill
I continue, most days, to take up each book from its place and check the signature, the date of acquisition and importantly, if possible, dip into it to refresh my memory at least. This enjoyable activity seems to be lasting as long as Lock-down and indeed is giving me real feelings of achievement and pleasure as I re-arrange; remove for a second reading; and in several cases, relay into labelled piles on the dining table for future family gifts. One volume which I kept out to re-read was John Julius Norwich’s Christmas Crackers, 1970-79, an annual anthology of quotes from many sources. And what a pleasure that has been. Imagine my delight when I happened across the following extract from Churchill’s book, Painting as a Pastime:

If you cannot read all your books, at any rate handle, or as it were, fondle them, – peer into them, let them fall open where they will, read from the first sentence that arrests the eye, set them back on the shelves with your own hands, arrange them on your own plan so that if you do not know what is in them, you at least know where they are. Let them be your friends; let them at any rate be your acquaintances. If they cannot enter the circle of your life, do not deny them at least a nod of recognition.”

Churchill’s advice could not more delightfully describe my two months, [so far, and continuing], of book sampling, re-acquaintance, re-arrangement, re-direction, re-reading in selected cases and re-alignment. Thanks to the exigencies of Coronavirus, I have stumbled over a most rewarding book- based sorting of an important part of my life.

Brugge during World War One
One re-read book, Bastion: Occupied Bruges in the First World War, acquired in the Brugge Museum Shop in 2017, caused further memories. Though a recent acquisition, I had quite forgotten the splendid story of a woman spy in WW1 from Dunkirk; Anna De Beir was a young widow trying to raise three children on the proceeds of a newspaper stall she ran in Dunkirk station. In June 2015, the stationmaster asked her to work for the French military intelligence and she accepted. She garnered information through her elder daughter who worked for Anna’s sister who managed a hotel, Pension Forrier on Krom Genthof, used by the German military. Meanwhile Anna also garnered continuing intelligence on the submarine base in Brugge. She physically smuggled her reports from Bruges to the Netherlands via a circuitous route through Boekhoute, always travelling alone before returning to Dunkirk and later back to begin her circuit again in Brugge. This involved, especially for a solo spy, negotiating a considerable number of barriers, but Anna did in fact manage to re-instate an important coastal connection between France and Holland She bribed a certain German guard on each return trip and developed a little group of informers including her seamstress; a friend who ran a jewellery stall on the Grote Markt in Brugge and the man who supplied fresh produce to her sister’s pension in Krom Genthof. 

During German occupation, Smedenpoort.

Anna was inevitably noticed and eventually picked up after only a few months, on the Maalse Steenweg in Sint Kruis on October 18, 2015. She was carrying only two letters from Belgian soldiers and questioned thoroughly, gave nothing away. Nor was any incriminating evidence against her ever found but she was, nonetheless, sentenced to death by the German authorities who could prove only that she smuggled letters from Belgian soldiers on the Yser. The only person empowered to decide on the capital condemnation of a female spy, following the Cavell execution earlier the same year which had caused an international storm of protest, was the Emperor and diplomats persuaded him to pardon Anna. In February 1916, after three months in Bruges prison, she was taken to Germany where she endured very harsh prison conditions in the notorious Belitz Prison, for the remainder of the war. She refused the offer of her release if she spied for Germany but survived and returned to Brugge in 1918 and on April 22 was awarded the French Iron Cross. Soon after the end of the war, Anna opened a hotel on Sint Annarei which became very popular with English guests and from where her guests could buy the memoir she had written.  

Given her history, in World War Two, Anna tried unsuccessfully to flee to Britain and eventually the Germans seized her hotel. In 1943 extraordinarily, she joined the Resistance near Ypres but was arrested on April 1st 1944 in Moorslede and sentenced to imprisonment in a German concentration camp. The train carrying her to Germany was ambushed by the British and she was released. Hearteningly, she lived until 1971 and died at 97 in Brugge. An extraordinary life by any measure.


German soldier inspecting papers.
The Kaiser in Brugge between 1914-18.